The closing item of Computer Gaming World’s September 1989 report on sound boards reads like a footnote. It opens with the words “Coming Soon to A PC near you” and tells readers that Creative Labs had announced a fall card called the Killer Kard. It would carry the Game Blaster’s 12-voice stereo output and the AdLib’s 11-voice output, plus a library of digitized sounds, a microphone input, a joystick port and a MIDI interface, and it was supposed to arrive in October for under $200.
Everything above that item concerned the card that already owned the market. The AdLib had the most software support in the survey, and the lab’s verdict was that the unreleased Creative card might be just what the market demanded if it delivered what was promised. Within three years a Creative card called the Sound Blaster was advertising itself in the same magazine as the PC sound standard. The evidence for how it got there sits in the magazine’s price lists and advertisements, so that is where this article reads it.
The incumbent’s report card
The September 1989 lab described the AdLib Music Synthesizer Card as an eleven-voice FM synthesizer, six voices melodic and five percussive, with an optional mode that sounds nine voices at once. The drums came from what the report called a clever trick, white-noise generation combined with FM synthesis. The card retailed for $195 and shipped with a Juke Box program holding 25 prerecorded songs, while the Visual Composer sequencer for writing your own cost another $50.
The survey is where the AdLib stood out. CGW asked 25 publishers what sound boards they planned to support, and eighteen put the AdLib at the top of the list; in the printed grid seventeen answered yes and one, Koei, said probably. The magazine’s explanation was modest. The AdLib had the most support because it had been on the market longest and sat in the middle of the price range. That describes an incumbent, not a technical winner. Sierra, for example, is marked yes for the AdLib, and the lab notes that Sierra sold an audio cassette of the AdLib and the Roland board playing music composed for its games.
A grid with a column for a card nobody could buy
The support grid had six columns: AdLib, Covox, Game Blaster, Innovation, Roland and the Creative card still called Killer Card. The last column is the surprising one. Seven publishers, Accolade, Cinemaware, Dynamix, Lucasfilm, Mindscape, Origin and Sierra, were marked yes for a board that was not on sale yet. The Game Blaster, which Creative had released in June as a stripped-down version of its Creative Music System, also had seven yeses. It cost $129.95, offered 12 voices from a preset library of 32 instruments, and came with a disk of 40 prerecorded songs. Origin was the only company in the grid to answer yes in every column, which is what a publisher hedging across a market that had not chosen yet looks like.
The other three boards sat at the edges of the price list. The Roland MT-32 was the richest-sounding board in the test at $550, which CGW judged beyond the casual gamer. The Covox Sound Master PC cost $89.95 and paired a programmable sound generator with an 8-bit digitizer. The Innovation SSI2001 cost $69 and used the three-voice SID chip from Commodore machines, and its support was weak. CGW’s conclusion was that the Roland led on performance, the AdLib on support, and the Game Blaster looked like the best buy, but it would not name a winner before the Creative card shipped.

Specifications the shipped card listed
The January 1990 dealer list
By January 1990 the mail-order dealer on 1-800-328-WARE, advertising in CGW’s issue 67, listed the AdLib card at $135, the Game Blaster at $97 and the Sound Blaster at “Call.” The bullet points under Creative’s two entries read 12 voices, 11 voices FM music, a digitized voice channel and voice input. Those bullets match the features announced for the Killer Kard, but the lab report never says the two names belong to one board, so this article treats them as a parallel, not a proven rename. A price printed as “Call” tells you the product was in the catalogue, not what it cost, so this list proves only that the card existed by then and which of its features the seller chose to print.
One detail matters for the argument. The September 1989 lab had given the AdLib eleven voices, and the dealer’s line for the Sound Blaster also says 11 voices of FM music. On FM alone, then, the new card matched the incumbent on paper, so the extra selling points were everything else on the list, above all the digitized voice and the voice input. That is why the argument was about digitized voice, not about FM.
The trade-in offer of autumn 1990
Ten months later a full-page advertisement from Brown-Wagh in CGW’s issue 76 printed the Sound Blaster at $239.95 and offered owners of an AdLib, a C/MS, a Covox or a Game Blaster a swap: send the old card plus $139.95, which the ad described as $100 off the suggested retail price. That is nearly $40 above the “under $200” CGW had been told to expect in 1989.
The ad’s shopping list shows what the card had become: digitized voice for sampling and playback, synthesized music marked “Adlib compatible,” a MIDI interface that needed a separate connector box, a text-to-speech converter, a microphone jack, a joystick port, a built-in amplifier and four free programs. The small print asked for 512K of RAM, DOS 2.0 or later, a CGA, EGA, VGA or Hercules display and external speakers. The microphone input, joystick port and MIDI interface that Creative’s September 1989 announcement promised all appear on this list, with the catch that MIDI needed the extra connector box.
Dealer prices in November 1990
The same November 1990 issue carries three mail-order dealers that stocked both cards, and each priced the Sound Blaster well above the AdLib. The dealer on 1-800-328-WARE had listed the AdLib at $135 ten months earlier, so its AdLib price fell by $25 over the year.
| Dealer in CGW issue 76 | AdLib card | Sound Blaster | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chips & Bits | $99 | $159 | $60 |
| Dealer on 1-800-328-WARE | $110 | $168 | $58 |
| A third dealer | $118 | $189 | $71 |
In relative terms the Sound Blaster cost about 53 to 61 percent more than the AdLib at the same shop. A difference of $58 to $71 was real money in a hobby where Chips & Bits listed AD&D’s Champions of Krynn at $32. Two games’ worth of price bought a feature list whose payoff depended on how much software used it, which helps explain the trade-in offer above. Creative and its distributor were selling that feature list at a premium, and the premium only paid off if software followed. A buyer who already owned an AdLib could, until January 15, 1991, close most of the gap through the trade-in, paying about $140 for the new card instead of $159 to $189.
Titles that show the difference
The cards are long gone from shops, but the games are not. GOG sells King’s Quest 4+5+6, Sierra’s fourth, fifth and sixth adventures, and its page says the package is powered by ScummVM, so its sound choices live in that program rather than in DOSBox. Sierra is marked yes for the AdLib, the Game Blaster, the Killer Card and the Roland in CGW’s 1989 grid, which makes its adventures a fair test of software written when the choice mattered. For digitized voices, GOG also sells Wolfenstein 3D with the Spear of Destiny expansion, and that page says the game is powered by DOSBox.
The emulator is free. DOSBox’s own readme, kept in the project’s SourceForge repository, says it emulates the PC speaker, the Creative CMS and Game Blaster, the Tandy three-voice chip, AdLib, the Sound Blaster family from the original to the 16, the Gravis Ultrasound and an MPU-401 MIDI interface. Mounting a folder and starting a game are covered in basic DOSBox configuration. This site does not point to downloads of the games themselves.
Support lists, then and later
The 1989 survey counted publishers who answered a magazine. The Brown-Wagh advertisement is a different kind of document, a partial list of companies “in development or currently supporting” the Sound Blaster, and it runs to 47 names. Besides game publishers such as Sierra, Lucasfilm, Electronic Arts, MicroProse, Origin and Accolade, it includes Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Microsoft, Autodesk and Voyetra, so it measures software in general, and it comes from the seller. The two lists cannot be subtracted from each other.
What they can show is direction. In September 1989 seven publishers had said yes to an unreleased Creative board, against eighteen for the AdLib, and all seven of those names, Accolade, Cinemaware, Dynamix, Lucasfilm, Mindscape, Origin and Sierra, appear again in Brown-Wagh’s Sound Blaster list a year later. By that autumn an advertisement could name more than forty companies, and the dealers’ own prices for the AdLib were falling toward $100. For the graphics side of the same hardware race, the video-card story of CGA, EGA and VGA follows a similar pattern of a cheap incumbent and a pricier standard.
Creative’s own price list, September 1992
By September 1992 Creative was advertising in CGW’s issue 98 under the headline “We’re lowering our standards,” calling the Sound Blaster the PC sound standard and cutting its price to “now just $149.” The ad credits the base card with multiple-source sampling and text-to-speech capability. The Sound Blaster Pro Basic, with stereo sound, a 20-voice capacity and a CD-ROM interface, was $229, and the full Sound Blaster Pro, with a MIDI kit and more software, was $299. Set beside the $239.95 list price in the 1990 ad, the base card had gotten cheaper while its family had grown upward.
The ad is printed between the two pages of CGW’s review of Wolfenstein 3-D, whose reviewer singled out the digitized sound, the scream of a guard who is shot and the realistic pump of the machine gun. Our Wolfenstein 3D case study covers that game’s structure; the point here is that by 1992 the magazine reviewed digitized voices as an ordinary part of a shooter, not a promise on a box.

Which card to pick when the setup screen asks
The magazine record does not settle why Creative won, but it shows what each choice gives a player today. AdLib mode gives the FM music publishers wrote for first, and the DOSBox readme calls its AdLib emulation almost perfect. The Sound Blaster adds the thing the September 1989 announcement was excited about, digitized voice and effects.
A workable rule: if a game from 1990 or later lets you choose, pick Sound Blaster, because that is the setting its voices and sampled effects were written for. If a game from before 1990 offers only AdLib and the PC speaker, take the AdLib and expect nothing digital. For games that run in DOSBox, such as GOG’s Wolfenstein 3D or an ordinary DOS copy, leave the emulator at its default, which the readme describes as Sound Blaster 16 level with address 220, IRQ 7 and DMA 1, sometimes with high DMA 5. If detection fails, the readme suggests trying sbtype=sbpro1, and sbtype=none for games that want Tandy DAC sound. GOG’s King’s Quest collection uses ScummVM instead, so its sound choices sit in that program’s settings.
What the magazine pages cannot tell you is whether the lower price, the longer feature list or the growing software list mattered most. They moved together over three years. Pure FM also has a case of its own, since it is exactly what a 1988 owner heard, and it is a reasonable choice when that is the experience you want.