Warcraft II and Blizzard’s 1995 Race With Command & Conquer

Warcraft II and Blizzard’s 1995 Race With Command & Conquer

Half a point separated the two games. In Computer Gaming World’s June 1996 reader poll, Warcraft II scored 10.50 among strategy games and Command & Conquer 10.00, a gap about the same as in the March issue, where the earlier poll had put Warcraft II at 10.60 and Command & Conquer at 10.01 with X-COM wedged between them. Warcraft II held first place in both polls, with Command & Conquer about half a point back each time. The numbers say less about which game was better than about how fast a studio that had renamed itself three times since 1991 had closed on Westwood.

Today’s official copy is a Windows release. Blizzard’s own Battle.net Shop lists Warcraft II: Battle.net Edition, which the page says includes the Beyond the Dark Portal expansion and requires a Battle.net account, and Blizzard’s news post on the release counts 28 missions across the Horde and Alliance campaigns before the expansion. Blizzard’s GOG announcement, written ahead of the series’ 25th anniversary, describes the Battle.net Edition for Windows, so it is a different thing from the 1995 DOS box this article describes. That GOG listing no longer turns up: GOG’s catalog search for this article returned no Warcraft title, so the Battle.net Shop is the only route verified here.

Silicon & Synapse, Chaos, then Blizzard

Blizzard began as Silicon & Synapse, founded by three UCLA graduates: Michael Morhaime, Allen Adham and Frank Pearce. It started developing its own software in 1993, with titles such as Rock n’ Roll Racing and The Lost Vikings, and renamed itself Chaos Studios that year. By April 1994 it was calling itself Ogre Studios, a name that Davidson & Associates, the distributor that had acquired it, rejected, and the company became Blizzard Entertainment later in 1994, the year it released Warcraft: Orcs & Humans. All of this follows a history of the company; accounts vary on the exact dates of the two middle names, so this article gives years.

The same history says the first Warcraft was inspired in part by the multiplayer side of Westwood’s strategy hit, and Computer Gaming World’s reviewer later called it a smash head-to-head fantasy wargame. That reputation created a problem for the sequel. The reviewer admitted he had expected it to land in the dreary “More of the Same” territory he had already seen in sequels such as X-COM: Terror from the Deep and Doom II. What he found instead was, in his words, essentially the same engine as the original, tuned up in graphics, ease of use and network play.

Six-step company timeline: Silicon & Synapse in 1991, Chaos Studios in 1993, Ogre Studios in 1994, Blizzard Entertainment in 1994, Warcraft: Orcs & Humans in 1994 and Warcraft II in 1995.
From Silicon & Synapse to Warcraft II: four names and two games in about four years.

Oil, ships and dragons

The headline change was the third resource. Blizzard’s own quickstart guide lists lumber, gold, oil and food on the command screen, and notes that oil is used in later scenarios. Oil pays for the navy. The 1996 review explains that the playfield had grown large enough to hold seas and big islands, so players often had to build ships just to defend themselves and then press the attack: Destroyers and Battleships on the surface, Gnomish Submarines and Goblin War-Turtles underneath. The air war was, in the reviewer’s words, less complex, but it added reconnaissance aircraft for scouting and Gryphons and Dragons for the attack.

The two sides also grew. The Humans gained Elves, Dwarves and Gnomes as allies, while the Orcs picked up Goblins and Trolls, and the units that came with them included demolition teams and Troll Berserkers. The campaigns changed with them. The reviewer wrote that scenarios now ranged from all-out bloodfests to diplomatic rescue missions, which goes beyond a plain base-and-battle formula.

The practical details of the review are worth setting beside a 2026 purchase. The price was $54.95, the game wanted a 486/33 or better, 8 MB of RAM, SVGA graphics, a hard drive and a double-speed CD-ROM drive, and it carried no copy protection. It was a DOS game that worked well under Windows 95. Because the action runs in real time, the reviewer advised prospective generals either to have quick mouse skills or to turn the game’s speed way down, since large battles needed a fair amount of micro-management.

Eight players and a map editor

The reviewer called multiplayer the best part of the game. It offered slots for up to eight players and aggressive computer opponents, from simple modem duels to big IPX-network battles with alliances and betrayals, and it shipped with built-in scenarios for two, four, six or eight players, several of them built around land, sea or air combat. Players could limit sighting range or even allow cheat codes, and the host’s options were visible to everyone who joined. The scenario design kit went further, because unit and building values could be changed, so a player who thought the Orcs should play like a horde could strip away their advanced units and make the grunts cheap and fast. Blizzard’s release notes still advertise up to seven computer-controlled opponents and a map editor.

There is a useful comparison in the same issue. A separate article on the multiplayer edition of Sid Meier’s turn-based empire builder pointed out that, unlike popular network games such as Warcraft II, a full game could take upward of 25 hours even at blitz speed. A game that could be finished in an evening was an easier fit for network play than one that needed a weekend.

What the reviewer wished for

The complaints were specific. The reviewer thought games of this kind needed branching campaigns, because the fixed order of scenarios gave some of them a puzzle quality, and the magazine’s summary box called the campaigns a little weak. He still recommended the game firmly. If you liked the original you should pick it up, he wrote, and for anyone with access to a network it moved into the “Must Buy” category.

Three cards for land, sea and air showing what Warcraft II added: new allies on each side and demolition teams on land, oil-fuelled ships and submersibles at sea, and reconnaissance aircraft, Gryphons and Dragons in the air.
What the sequel added on land, at sea and in the air, as the March 1996 review lists it.

Reader scores and a rival’s awards

The reader polls show how closely the two games ran. A monthly poll measures what readers are still playing and enjoying, while an annual award answers a different question, so the two should not be forced into one verdict. The magazine’s 1996 Premier Awards make the point. Its editors’ Strategy Game of the Year ended in a tie between Command & Conquer and Heroes of Might and Magic. The write-up called Command & Conquer an outstanding descendant of Dune II, praised its different unit types for the Global Defense Initiative and Brotherhood of Nod, and noted that some players would say the real-time action degenerates into mob warfare.

Warcraft II appears in the same awards piece as one of four other finalists that could have won in a weaker year. The writers credited it with insanely addictive properties, especially over a network, and listed larger maps, a scenario editor, new sea and air troops and SVGA graphics. That combination is a fair summary of the rivalry. Command & Conquer shared the trophy for its real-time combat and its distinct sides, and Warcraft II kept the reader polls with a design the magazine kept praising for network play.

MeasureWarcraft IICommand & Conquer
Reader poll, March 1996 issue10.60, first10.01, third
Reader poll, June 1996 issue10.50, first10.00, second
Editors’ Strategy Game of the Year, 1996FinalistCo-winner with Heroes of Might and Magic

Releases after the box

The story of the game’s editions is easier to follow in order than in prose, and each step here comes from a Blizzard page or a magazine of the time.

  1. 1995: Warcraft II: Tides of Darkness reaches stores, with 28 missions across two campaigns.
  2. By June 1996: an advertisement in Computer Gaming World announces Beyond the Dark Portal, with 24 new scenarios and 50 custom maps.
  3. Later: the Battle.net Edition bundles the game and the expansion as a Windows release.
  4. Ahead of the series’ 25th anniversary: Blizzard and GOG announce a rerelease with a high-resolution build and a classic build, and today the Battle.net Shop sells the Battle.net Edition.

Blizzard’s GOG announcement is explicit about the difference between the builds. A GOG-enhanced version added support for high-resolution displays and multiplayer over a local network, and a classic version kept the original SVGA graphics and matchmaking through the classic Battle.net service. A separate Warcraft II: Remastered has its own page in the same shop. That page says the package includes the Beyond the Dark Portal campaign, and it lists Windows 10 64-bit as the minimum system together with an internet connection and a Battle.net account.

Should you play the DOS original or the Battle.net Edition?

Start with the Battle.net Edition, because it is the only official release of the original game this article could verify and it contains both campaigns, the 28 missions of Tides of Darkness plus the expansion’s 24. It is a Windows release, so it will not reproduce the DOS-era setup that the 1996 review describes, from the sound-card support to the advice about turning the game speed down. Anyone who wants the 1995 DOS release itself will find no official sale in the stores checked. The Remastered edition is a separate purchase with its own requirements. For a first run the choice matters little, because the reviewer in 1996 and Blizzard’s page today describe the same two campaigns, the same war on land, sea and air, and the same map editor.

The 1996 review, the reader polls and the awards write-up come from Computer Gaming World issues 140 and 143, and the current sales pages come from Blizzard, all checked in October of 2026.

About the author — Sung Hwan Cho, a Seoul-born industrial designer, runs and edits DOS Attic, a site about how DOS-era games and PC hardware were made and how to play them legally today. Dates, credits and figures here are checked against developer and publisher statements, period magazines and credits databases. Corrections are welcome at 4ddesigner@naver.com.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top