Why Doom’s First Episode Crashed a Wisconsin Server on Launch Night

Why Doom’s First Episode Crashed a Wisconsin Server on Launch Night

Doom did not invent shareware, and it was not even the first id game to prove the model. A trade feature in the first issue of Game Developer magazine, dated January 1994, already credited Wolfenstein 3D with beating the shareware record held by id’s own Commander Keen series by more than five times. What Doom added was reach, and the sources show unusually clearly how a studio that owned both the game and the pipeline built it.

The groundwork id had already laid

The Game Developer feature, dated January 1994, describes the machinery before the launch. Wolfenstein 3D’s first ten levels were free and, in the magazine’s words, public domain, while the rest were sold through Apogee; the details are in the Wolfenstein 3D feature on six episodes sold direct.

id had also decided who would sell Doom. According to the same piece, the staff felt that Apogee, the company behind the shareware model id had used, was not equipped to handle the phone orders a game like Doom would bring, so id took over distribution itself. It contracted a company called Digital Magnetics to take the calls, and Apogee later hired the same firm, a turn the article calls ironic. The whole company, the article says, comprised seven people.

Midnight on the tenth, 125 slots

The launch night is told in CGW’s July 1994 profile of id. The company announced a December release and advertised that the shareware version would appear on the 10th at midnight on the University of Wisconsin’s computer system, which puts the date at December 10, 1993. That system allowed 125 users on its FTP site, and all 125 slots were full that night. Jay Wilbur, who handled id’s operations, could not get on to upload the game, so he asked the system operator to clear space. The operator raised the user limit by 50, users poured in again, and Wilbur barely made it into one of the last slots.

Hundreds of other people watched him upload through an IRC channel. The second the upload finished, thousands on the channel hit the Wisconsin system and crashed it twice. The profile says word of the game had already spread through the press and the online networks, and that anticipation had reached a fevered pitch. The crush was announced in advance, not an accident of one server.

Free by modem, nearly free by post

id’s own advertisement in the same CGW issue shows the offer in one sentence. Players could order the entire Doom trilogy for $40.00, or get episode one, Knee-Deep in the Dead, for the cost of shipping and handling, or fetch episode one from the Software Creations bulletin board at speeds up to 14.4K baud. A free episode that cost only postage reached people with no modem, and a free one on a bulletin board reached people with one.

CGW’s March 1994 review, headed “Hell’s Bells and Whistles”, names the three episodes the $40 bought: Knee-Deep in the Dead, The Shores of Hell and Inferno. Game Developer adds that id expected foreign orders to reach a third of Doom sales thanks to a better foreign distribution deal, and that it had built the characters from graphics instead of fonts so distributors could translate the text without id recompiling the game.

Five steps from id's own distribution plan through the December 10 FTP upload, the crash of the Wisconsin server, the mail and modem offer and the commercial sequel that included episode one.
How the free episode moved, in the order the sources describe it.

Hardware the engine demanded in 1993

The system requirements printed in CGW’s review were a 386DX or better, with a 486 recommended, 4 MB of RAM, VGA graphics and 17 MB of hard disk space, with support for the Sound Blaster and compatibles. id’s July 1994 ad adds that the digitized sound effects needed a 100 percent Sound Blaster compatible card, a Gravis UltraSound or a Pro Audio Spectrum-16. The reviewer found Doom easy to install and configure, up and running in minutes, with screen size, detail, sound and controls all adjustable.

Game Developer explains the performance. John Carmack broke the map into small sectors and reordered them so the engine could use the 486’s internal cache, and a medium-detail mode doubled the pixel width horizontally and tripled the speed on slower machines. Only two routines were written in assembler, one to stretch a column vertically and one to texture-map a row, with everything else in C. Carmack estimated that writing the whole game in assembler would make it only 15 percent faster.

Running the 1993 files today

The Steam listing for DOOM + DOOM II states that the original DOS versions of DOOM (1993) and DOOM II are included, and the GOG listing for the same bundle says the same for its version. id’s GitHub release of the source says you still need real DOOM data to work with the code and that the DOS code was not released because of a copyrighted sound library. Carmack’s 1997 note released the source for non-profit use, and the repository now carries it under the GNU General Public License 2.0. In the same note Carmack calls the basic rendering concept, lines of constant Z with fixed light shading per band, dead-on, while saying the implementation could be improved a great deal.

Multiplayer for four, and tools left in the open

Multiplayer was built in from the start. The ad promises four-player combat over a network and two-player action over a modem, and the small print says the options need an IPX network, a modem or a serial link. Game Developer reports that id expected fewer than 10 percent of players to use it, but wanted the experience for later games, and that Carmack wrote a network driver in a day when an outside contractor failed to deliver one.

The same feature records id’s view of modification. Wolfenstein 3D had attracted hackers who made editors and altered games from the free ten levels, and Apogee argued that this hurt sales. id took a different view, saying people had the right to use the game as they liked, and planned the same for Doom, including releasing some technical specifications. The guard-rail was a checksum: if the game had been altered, it would display a message that the version was not the original and where to get the original.

Physical models and a NeXT workstation

The tools were unusual for a PC studio. Game Developer says the level editor Romero wrote for Doom took five human-months on NeXTSTEP, a platform that Carmack had bought a NeXT cube to use, and that most of id’s code was ANSI C. The monsters began as physical models made with a professional model designer, Gregor Punchatz. Each sat on a revolving tray with eight pegs, one for each of the eight viewpoints the engine needed, was moved frame by frame, and was digitized through a video camera into the NeXT machine and then into a PC running Deluxe Paint.

Sound was a lower priority. The article says id had no sound programmer and added Gravis UltraSound support only after angry letters from owners. CGW’s reviewer, for his part, praised the digitized effects for Sound Blaster owners and counted eight types of ordinary monster, each with its own attacks, durability and voice.

The sequel that kept episode one in the box

The CGW profile closes with id’s plan for the sequel. It notes that, although id continued to surprise the market by sticking with shareware, the sequel would be a commercial release. Doom II would use the same engine with 27 to 30 new levels and six new creatures, and Carmack said id would include episode one so that players who found the new game too hard could go back and train on it.

That decision keeps the free episode doing a job. In the first game it was the advertisement. In the second it became a training course packaged with the product. The engine behind both is the one Raven took for a fantasy shooter, as described in Heretic and the engine Raven borrowed from id.

Three cards comparing the three accounts of Tom Hall's exit from Game Developer 1994, CGW 1994 and Game Informer 2011 by who speaks, what they say and when.
Three accounts of the same exit, and the part they share.

Who left whom: three accounts of Tom Hall’s exit

The sources agree that creative director Tom Hall left before Doom was finished and disagree about the verb. Game Developer, in January 1994, says Carmack and Romero felt Hall’s creativity was coming into conflict with gameplay, that Hall insisted on continuity in the storyline, and that he left to become project manager at Apogee. CGW’s profile says Hall wanted to inject a story and make the environment more interactive, the rest of the team did not want a story slowing the action, and “Hall and id parted ways.” It dates the hire of his replacement as designer, Sandy Petersen, to July 1993.

Game Informer’s 2011 report on the GDC talk by Romero and Hall gives the third version: Hall left before the game was completed because of feelings of stifled creativity. The same report says id stopped Doom for three weeks to make the Wolfenstein 3D port for the Super NES because the person they had hired failed to deliver it.

The first two accounts come from reporting at id in 1994 and describe the team’s reasoning. The third is a 2011 summary of a talk given by Hall and Romero themselves, seventeen years later, and it is the only one that reflects the view of the person who left. A cautious reading keeps only what all three share: the break came over design direction, and it came before the game shipped. CGW alone ties it to Petersen’s hire in July 1993, which suggests the timing without proving it. Which side moved first, and in which month, is better treated as open, which is why this article names no date for the exit.

The launch night comes from CGW’s July 1994 profile of id, the distribution plans from Game Developer’s January 1994 feature, and Hall’s exit from three accounts that disagree, all re-read in mid-October 2026.

About the author — Sung Hwan Cho, a Seoul-born industrial designer, runs and edits DOS Attic, a site about how DOS-era games and PC hardware were made and how to play them legally today. Dates, credits and figures here are checked against developer and publisher statements, period magazines and credits databases. Corrections are welcome at 4ddesigner@naver.com.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top